top of page
Search
Writer's pictureKansas City's Sports Cleanout

Taking a Swing at Vintage Baseball Bats

Vintage baseball bats hold a special place in the hearts of collectors and enthusiasts alike, each one telling a unique story of baseball's rich history. Bats, those quintessential tools of the baseball trade, possess a timeless allure that transcends the boundaries of time and generations. Among the various categories of vintage bats we will discuss in the following post are store model bats, vintage game used bats, and vintage index bats. 


Model Bats: Vintage store model baseball bats produced by such companies as Hillerich & Bradsby, Hanna Batrite, Spalding, Adirondack and Zinn Beck are desirable to collectors based on different factors. The pricing depends on length and condition. In the world of bat collecting, length plays a crucial role, with longer bats typically fetching higher prices (36” v. 33”). Additionally, the condition of the bat can significantly impact its value, as collectors seek well-preserved pieces that reflect the glory of bygone eras. Player endorsed can play a role in the value as well, for example a Babe Ruth store model bat from his playing era will fetch more money than a Nellie Fox store model bat from his playing era. 


A 1940's Jimmie Foxx Store Model Bat 36" sold in 2021 for $100.

Game Used Bats: Vintage game used bats add another layer of intrigue to the world of baseball memorabilia. These bats, once wielded by legendary players on the diamond, carry the scars and markings of their time in action. Collectors value the authenticity and historical significance of game used bats, which can provide a tangible connection to baseball's past. Whether it's the distinct markings left by a particular player or the wear and tear from countless swings, these bats serve as tangible artifacts that transport enthusiasts back to the golden age of the sport. Vintage game used bats are much more scarce than the retail store model bats of course. Determining if a bat is game used can hinge on many different factors such as company markings, length, and weight. 


An Alex Rodriguez Game Used Bat sold for $396 in 2023.

Index and College Index Bats: Vintage index and college index baseball bats represent a unique subcategory within baseball bat collecting. These bats, often produced for the minor leagues or college institutions, carry a distinct charm and historical relevance. These bats are great for a collector on a budget that wants a bat that is very similar to the one that the actual player used. For example, a Johnny Bench game used bat might cost thousands of dollars, but a Johnny Bench index bat might only cost $75. The only difference between the index and true game used bat could be a half inch in length and an ounce or two in weight. College index bats are typically a star player such as Jackie Robinson, but underneath his name it will read University of Kansas. No, this doesn’t mean that Jackie did a hitting clinic with the Kansas Jayhawks or was a coach for them. It means the college team ordered these bats. The aforementioned bat would typically sell for $25-50 as they are seen as less desirable. 


A Brooks Robinson College Index Bat is currently for sale on eBay for $29.95.

In conclusion, vintage baseball bats offer collectors a captivating journey through the baseball’s past. From store model bats associated with renowned brands to game used relics that witnessed unforgettable moments, each bat contributes to the mosaic of baseball history. The specialized world of index and college index bats adds depth to collections, while the display of these artifacts pays homage to the enduring legacy of America's favorite pastime. As these vintage bats stand as silent witnesses to the evolution of baseball, collectors and enthusiasts continue to cherish them as cherished pieces of sporting heritage.  Sports Cleanout is always looking to buy vintage baseball bats of all sizes and conditions here in the Midwest. Based in Kansas City, Sports Cleanout will travel Missouri, Kansas, Iowa, Nebraska, Arkansas, and Oklahoma to check out your collection. 

7 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All

Comentários


bottom of page